Comparison: Houchin’s “Larry Barrett Veterans’ Memory Care Act” vs. Veterans’ Dementia & Memory Care Access and Accountability Act

Criteria Larry Barrett Veterans’ Memory Care Act (Houchin) Veterans’ Dementia & Memory Care Access and Accountability Act (Taylor)
Funding source and protection Unspecified; no dedicated, protected funding line Dedicated, protected VA budget line; no reprogramming without statute
Access standards (wait time) No enforceable wait-time guarantee Maximum 30 days from diagnosis/referral to placement
Access standards (travel distance) No enforceable distance cap Maximum 40 miles/60 minutes unless veteran opts otherwise
Dementia-capable provider standards Not defined Mandatory dementia-capable certification, training, safety, BH integration
Rural adjustments Silent on rural rate boosts and capacity-building 15% rural reimbursement enhancement + capital upgrade grants
Network expansion/credentialing General “facilitate/expedite” language 60-day fast-track approval or denial; public provider directory
Interoperability and continuity of care No EHR interoperability requirement Mandatory interoperable EHR with VA, med reconciliation, incident reporting
Caregiver support Not addressed 30 days/year respite, stipend alignment with COLA, care navigators
Transparency and public reporting No public dashboard; limited accountability Monthly-updated public dashboard: wait times, distance, capacity, staffing, outcomes, spend
Enforcement mechanisms None specified Clawbacks, referral suspensions, public non-compliance listing
Veteran right of appeal Not specified Independent appeals board with binding authority and reimbursements
Fraud, waste, and abuse controls Not specified Pre-auth standards, post-payment review, conflict-of-interest checks
Sunset and external review No sunset or GAO review requirement GAO review at 5 years; 6-year sunset unless reauthorized
Scope and duplication Rebrands existing VA tools; risks duplicating authority Targets actual bottlenecks: standards, funding, capacity, transparency, enforcement
Accountability to veterans Press-release metrics; no real-time proof Real-time, public metrics with enforceable thresholds and penalties